Naming issues with the Russian Leather Waxcap:
Okay, so, illustrated above is a mushroom that is common EVERY YEAR in our redwood forests throughout CA, and with other trees farther north.
It is called Camarophyllus russocoriaceus by almost everyone, and that name is good in the sense that everyone understands what you’re talking about: a small, waxy-cap like fungus, white overall sometimes with pink or yellow tones, and a strong odor of cedar.
However, that name originally refers to a European fungus, and as in so many cases, the name probably should not be applied to our entity in Western North America. 
Here’s the kicker, though: we already have a name for this. That’s right. A western North American collection of a mushroom matching this description was described as Hygrophorus lawrencei by Hesler and Smith way back when. So we are unnecessarily using a European name! Goddammit! Basically, my point is that the community of fungal enthusiasts has been somewhere between lazy/apathetic towards and understandably daunted/overwhelmed by the mass of names that could potentially refer to our North American species in cases where we’ve been using European names.
So I say - hit the books! Resurrect old names! Those with (Western) North American type collections should be used until proven otherwise. 
Oh, PS - these things aren’t really in either Hygrophorus, Hygrocybe, or Camarophyllus anymore. They’ve been shown to be in Cuphophyllus, but not transferred.
So, yeah, if you want to give an old-time mushroom taxonomist a migraine, walk up to them with this mushroom and mention that you’ve got a very typical collection of Cuphophyllus lawrencei. Sure to draw some stares/angry looks.

Naming issues with the Russian Leather Waxcap:

Okay, so, illustrated above is a mushroom that is common EVERY YEAR in our redwood forests throughout CA, and with other trees farther north.

It is called Camarophyllus russocoriaceus by almost everyone, and that name is good in the sense that everyone understands what you’re talking about: a small, waxy-cap like fungus, white overall sometimes with pink or yellow tones, and a strong odor of cedar.

However, that name originally refers to a European fungus, and as in so many cases, the name probably should not be applied to our entity in Western North America. 

Here’s the kicker, though: we already have a name for this. That’s right. A western North American collection of a mushroom matching this description was described as Hygrophorus lawrencei by Hesler and Smith way back when. So we are unnecessarily using a European name! Goddammit! Basically, my point is that the community of fungal enthusiasts has been somewhere between lazy/apathetic towards and understandably daunted/overwhelmed by the mass of names that could potentially refer to our North American species in cases where we’ve been using European names.

So I say - hit the books! Resurrect old names! Those with (Western) North American type collections should be used until proven otherwise. 

Oh, PS - these things aren’t really in either Hygrophorus, Hygrocybe, or Camarophyllus anymore. They’ve been shown to be in Cuphophyllus, but not transferred.

So, yeah, if you want to give an old-time mushroom taxonomist a migraine, walk up to them with this mushroom and mention that you’ve got a very typical collection of Cuphophyllus lawrencei. Sure to draw some stares/angry looks.

  1. ink-bloom reblogged this from strandedonthemainland
  2. spectacularbear reblogged this from strandedonthemainland
  3. savanna19961 reblogged this from strandedonthemainland
  4. the-picture-of-dorian-gay reblogged this from strandedonthemainland
  5. hopeless-wanderer-7 reblogged this from strandedonthemainland
  6. strandedonthemainland reblogged this from mycobratpack and added:
    mycobratpack
  7. silvabvk reblogged this from wellmetkinsman
  8. beneaththeweepingwillow reblogged this from faerieforests
  9. vargstenenn reblogged this from venomhigh
  10. venomhigh reblogged this from paleinyourshadow
  11. missmichiko reblogged this from wellmetkinsman
  12. erickfast reblogged this from faerieforests
  13. planetary-drive reblogged this from wellmetkinsman
  14. salemsprincess reblogged this from bammpot
  15. bammpot reblogged this from wellmetkinsman
  16. resiakayna reblogged this from wellmetkinsman
  17. paleinyourshadow reblogged this from faerieforests
  18. wellmetkinsman reblogged this from faerieforests
  19. faerieforests reblogged this from mycobratpack
  20. tahleebird reblogged this from mycobratpack
  21. asonmambulist reblogged this from cloud-pleaser
  22. measurementoftheobserver reblogged this from mycology
  23. moonstr reblogged this from grossmagic
  24. reveonn reblogged this from smurfberries
  25. gumusservi reblogged this from grossmagic
  26. grossmagic reblogged this from mycology
  27. cloud-pleaser reblogged this from mycology
Short URL for this post: http://tmblr.co/ZBEo6xQxPiem